Minnesota Supreme Court rules in favor of rail-trail in landowner case
Submitted by Brent Hugh on Wed, 08/04/2004 - 8:48pm
The Grand Forks Herald reports that the Minnesota Supreme Court has ruled in favor of a rail-trail in a case brought by adjoining landowners. The case is similar to one brought by Missouri landowners against the Katy Trail. In the case before the Missouri Supreme Court, the landowners won and will receive a cash payment because converting the rail line to trail usage was judged to be a "taking".
In Minnesota, with different laws in effect, the state court reached the opposite conclusion:
In Minnesota, with different laws in effect, the state court reached the opposite conclusion:
The Minnesota State Supreme Court ruled Thursday that 2 miles of former railroad beds along the Paul Bunyan State Trail belong to the state, not to private landowners.
The decision overturned a 2003 state Court of Appeals decision regarding a small stretch of the trail, which runs from the Brainerd area to Bemidji.
Trail advocates hailed the ruling as a victory for the state's 500 miles of railroad-turned-public-trails. But a key defendant vowed to bring the case before the U.S. Supreme Court. . . .
The DNR paid the Burlington Northern Railroad $1.5 million in 1991 for the rights of way to parts of the trail near Walker. When three landowners blockaded that part of the trail in 1998, the DNR sued.
In 2002, a Hubbard County district judge ruled in favor of the railroad. The state Court of Appeals ruled last year in favor of the landowners, who contended that deeds from 1898 said the railroad had an easement and that once the tracks were removed, the rights of way returned to landowners.
Tags:
- News
- 2002
- 2003
- 2012
- 2013
- court
- katy trail
- katy-trail
- laws
- missouri
- rights
- rules
- trail
- trails
- Business
- Court of Appeals
- Katy Trail
- Law
- Minnesota
- Minnesota State Supreme Court
- Minnesota Supreme Court
- Missouri
- Missouri Supreme Court
- Missouri-Kansas-Texas Railroad
- Paul Bunyan State Trail
- Paul Bunyan State Trail
- Politics
- Rail trail
- Rail transport
- State court
- State supreme court
- Supreme Court of the United States
- The Grand Forks Herald
- U.S. Supreme Court
« Previous story: "River-to-River" trail pushed in Lawrence, KS
» Next story: 2004 RAGBRAI concludes
Join MoBikeFed's Advocacy Network
MoBikeFed is a statewide group of people like you, working together for better bicycling, walking, and trails in Missouri. When you join our advocacy network you receive occasional important advocacy alerts and bicycle, pedestrian, and trails news from around Missouri.
Working together we make a real difference! Join our advocacy network:
Working together we make a real difference! Join our advocacy network:
Related pages
Current topics...
Archives...
Want better bicycling and walking in Missouri?
We rely on the support of members like you. Please join, renew, or donate today.
- Home
- JOIN/DONATE
- News/Info
- Missouri Bicycling, Running, Trails
- Bicycle Skills and Safety
- Missouri Bike/Ped Law
- Clubs and Organizations
- Bike Shops
- Running Shops
- Bicycling, Running, Trails-related Businesses
- Ride, Run, Walk, Hike, Triathlon, and Events Calendars
- Bicycles on Amtrak
- Maps and Routes
- Trails and Trail Maps
- IBikeMO.org
- Planning a Missouri bicycle trip
- Gravel and Bikepacking Maps & Routes
- Bicycle & Touring Routes
- Advocacy
- Campaigns
- Our Legislative Platform
- Complete Streets
- Statewide Rock Island Trail
- Statewide Trail Vision - Quad State Trail
- Bicycle Friendly Missouri
- Walk Friendly Missouri
- Safe Routes to School
- MoDOT funding crisis
- High Priority Bike/Ped Project List
- Anti-harassment laws in cities & statewide
- Updating the basic bicycle law
- Our Vision for MoDOT
- Our Vision for MPOs/RPCs
- Our Vision for Cities & Counties
- Bicycle, pedestrian, trails plans across MO
- Protecting Vulnerable Road Users
- Vision Zero
- Missouri Trail Towns
- Store
- About