More on Boonville Bridge legal situation
Submitted by Brent Hugh on Thu, 07/27/2006 - 8:43pm
As part of the ongoing coverage of the Boonville MKT Bridge legal case, the Carthage Press recently reported that:
The reason is that the decision includes a simple error of fact.
The original Interim Trail Agreement that created the Katy Trail in fact gives the Missouri DNR two distinct rights in the MKT bridge:
Although it may be argued, and Judge Kinder has apparently accepted the argument, that the first right is a conditional future right andthe conditions necessary for the state to exercise that right in the MKT bridge have never been met, no such argument can be maintained can be put forward for the second right.
That right--to keep the bridge in place "for transportation purposes" began as soon as the agreement was signed and has no pre-conditions.
This second right is, apparently, not addressed in Judge Kinders decision--he appears to have entirely overlooked it. That error of fact could very easily become the basis for overturning the decision on appeal.
This second right--the right to keep the bridge in place of transportation purposes--is important because it keeps the entire Katy railroad corridor intact and connected at several points to the national railroad network. Those connections are essential in order to maintain the Katy's status as a railbanked rail line and that is exactly why this seemingly esoteric right was included in the agreement in the first place.
Kinder ruled in Nixon's case that the Department of Natural Resources had no property interest in or current contract rights to the Boonville bridge.The article went on to point out the contract rights that Judge Kinder ruled on:
Opponents had pointed to a 1987 agreement by which the state acquired 200 miles of rail line from the Missouri-Kansas-Texas-Railroad for use as a trail that could someday revert to an active rail line, if necessary. That deal kept ownership of the bridge with the railroad but gave the state the right to use it for the trail if it assumed liability on terms acceptable to the railroad. Those conditions never have been met, Kinder said.This article together with discussions the MOBikeFed board has had with lawyers who worked on the Boonville Bridge case indicates that there is significant chance of this decision being overturned on appeal.
The reason is that the decision includes a simple error of fact.
The original Interim Trail Agreement that created the Katy Trail in fact gives the Missouri DNR two distinct rights in the MKT bridge:
- To be able to assume trail use of the bridge if certain conditions are met
- To have the bridge continue to be kept in place and maintained for transportation purposes
Although it may be argued, and Judge Kinder has apparently accepted the argument, that the first right is a conditional future right andthe conditions necessary for the state to exercise that right in the MKT bridge have never been met, no such argument can be maintained can be put forward for the second right.
That right--to keep the bridge in place "for transportation purposes" began as soon as the agreement was signed and has no pre-conditions.
This second right is, apparently, not addressed in Judge Kinders decision--he appears to have entirely overlooked it. That error of fact could very easily become the basis for overturning the decision on appeal.
This second right--the right to keep the bridge in place of transportation purposes--is important because it keeps the entire Katy railroad corridor intact and connected at several points to the national railroad network. Those connections are essential in order to maintain the Katy's status as a railbanked rail line and that is exactly why this seemingly esoteric right was included in the agreement in the first place.
Tags:
- News
- 2006
- abandonment
- board
- boonville
- boonville bridge
- bridge
- conditions
- exercise
- first
- kansas
- katy trail
- katy-trail
- kinder
- missouri
- missouri bicycle federation
- mobikefed
- points
- resources
- rights
- terms
- trail
- transportation
- Boonslick Bridge
- Boonville
- Boonville Bridge
- Boonville MKT Bridge
- Carthage Press
- Cooper County, Missouri
- Howard County, Missouri
- Kansas
- Katy Trail
- Katy Trail
- Katy Trail State Park
- Missouri
- Missouri
- Missouri-Kansas-Texas (MKT) Bridge
- Missouri-Kansas-Texas Railroad
- Missouri–Kansas–Texas Railroad
- MKT bridge
- Natural Resources
- Nixon
- Rail trail
- Texas
- Trail
- transportation
Join MoBikeFed's Advocacy Network
MoBikeFed is a statewide group of people like you, working together for better bicycling, walking, and trails in Missouri. When you join our advocacy network you receive occasional important advocacy alerts and bicycle, pedestrian, and trails news from around Missouri.
Working together we make a real difference! Join our advocacy network:
Working together we make a real difference! Join our advocacy network:
Related pages
Current topics...
Archives...
Want better bicycling and walking in Missouri?
We rely on the support of members like you. Please join, renew, or donate today.
- Home
- JOIN/DONATE
- News/Info
- Missouri Bicycling, Running, Trails
- Bicycle Skills and Safety
- Missouri Bike/Ped Law
- Clubs and Organizations
- Bike Shops
- Running Shops
- Bicycling, Running, Trails-related Businesses
- Ride, Run, Walk, Hike, Triathlon, and Events Calendars
- Bicycles on Amtrak
- Maps and Routes
- Trails and Trail Maps
- IBikeMO.org
- Planning a Missouri bicycle trip
- Gravel and Bikepacking Maps & Routes
- Bicycle & Touring Routes
- Advocacy
- Campaigns
- Our Legislative Platform
- Complete Streets
- Statewide Rock Island Trail
- Statewide Trail Vision - Quad State Trail
- Bicycle Friendly Missouri
- Walk Friendly Missouri
- Safe Routes to School
- MoDOT funding crisis
- High Priority Bike/Ped Project List
- Anti-harassment laws in cities & statewide
- Updating the basic bicycle law
- Our Vision for MoDOT
- Our Vision for MPOs/RPCs
- Our Vision for Cities & Counties
- Bicycle, pedestrian, trails plans across MO
- Protecting Vulnerable Road Users
- Vision Zero
- Missouri Trail Towns
- Store
- About